“Plus One” NCAA Football Playoff

In the pre-season there was the usual talk of Playoff vs. BCS in college football. You had your arguments both ways. A large playoff will likely never happen but the idea of a “Plus One” game is hard to argue with. The teams are sitting idle for the next month anyway.

Let’s play with the idea of this scenario. Using the BCS to determine the top four teams we will seed them as they were ranked. This still leaves too many teams out but we will go with it. The higher seeds host the games in the first round. What team wouldn’t want to the cash of an extra home game? This game can take place the week after the regular college football season still leaving the two title contenders the big layoff before the title game. The Championship game still lands in it’s original destination.

Joining me is my NFL Footballderdash Nemesis, Kelloggs23.

#4 @ #1

TINO Members voted this game 85% in favor of Oklahoma. No love for the #1 team in the country? Most of that could stem from the fact they don’t play a conference title game and sit back and watch as teams are bumped off. It’s not so much that they don’t win another game to prove themselves as it is that they don’t have to face the chance of losing a conference title game that others do. Not their fault, they are in the Big Ten. What is their fault is dropping a game to Illinois late in the season. They win that game and they get more respect here. I thought Lou Holtz was going to have a vein pop in his head as he expressed that Oklahoma deserved to be in the title game. They are the hot team beating up on #1 Missouri 38-17 in the Big 12 title game. Yeah, it was Missouri you say but they were #1 in the same system that now puts Ohio State #1. I have to lean with Lou here. I think that Oklahoma smashes OSU in the mouth in a way they didn’t get hit in the Big Ten this year.

TINO: Oklahoma wins 34-27

First off, I don’t think that Ohio State deserves to be in the National Championship because they play in a conference without a championship game and how do they continue to climb in the polls if they aren’t winning games. In this game I think it will be decently close, but Oklahoma is just plain old better than OSU. Ohio State needs to be ahead so they can run Beanie Wells and let him punish a defense, but I don’t see Oklahoma being down much in this game because of Bradford & Kelly. Playing at home gives OSU help, but not enough.

Kelloggs23: Oklahoma wins 27-17

Now to VT @ LSU…

#3 @ #2

TINO Members voted this one 87% in favor of LSU. With LSU making it to the Big Show, being the first team to do so with two losses, it makes you think that the SEC Champion has an automatic bid. Granted the two losses were tough OT losses (and Miles will tell you despite those losses they were the best 60 minute team int he country?) they were still losses….they count as losses. LSU took the first meeting 48-7 in their second game of the season. Virginia Tech also had two losses this season but it should be noted that both the teams they lost to were ranked #2 at the time. They avenged the loss to Boston College in the ACC title game and ended the season on a five game winning steak. Despite all that, LSU is the better 60 minute team (nudge to Miles) and would take this game at home.

TINO: LSU wins 42-24
The real National Championship. Yes, I know that LSU beat VaTech by 41 pts earlier in the year, but VaTech was trying to figure out their offense at that point and have been one of the hottest teams as of late and showed more in their conference championship game than LSU
in my opinion by blowing out a higher ranked BC, but then they get jumped by everybody’s darlings LSU. With that said, I think LSU will win this game because it is in Baton Rouge. LSU is the complete package, but they just don’t seem to be able to consistently put it
together and that has hurt them. I know their losses have come in triple-OT, but if they are so good they never would have had to go to OT in the first place. They benefited from some very gusty play calling late in games by Miles and if one of those didn’t go their
way, it could be a totally different story.

Kelloggs23: LSU wins 34-20

So this leaves us with a National Title game of Oklahoma vs. LSU. Who wins this game?

tag: , , , , , , , , , ,


3 Responses to ““Plus One” NCAA Football Playoff”

  1. Patrick Says:

    Now THAT game I would want to see. LSU and OSU is going to be boring, but LSU and OU would be awesome. I would still have to go with LSU in a close one.

  2. Tino Says:

    I would still have to think LSU would take it as well. but would still leave a bad taste knowing they had two losses.

  3. Bryan Says:

    OSU doesn’t deserve to be there because they don’t play a conference game? Would you be saying that if Notre Dame went undefeated and was in the national title game? I don’t think so. LSU lost twice to two unranked opponents. They are the ones that truly don’t belong in the game. Hawaii got screwed out of the title game because of the preseason rankings, which are a whole other crock of crap. I bet Hawaii could give any team in the top 5 a good game.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: